CONTACT: [email protected]
Civic Federation offers policymakers alternative tax designs beyond the flat-versus-graduated income tax debate
CHICAGO — Discussions about Illinois’ individual income tax often focus on whether the State should retain its flat tax or adopt a graduated structure. A new report by the Civic Federation, More Than a Tax Rate: Understanding the Choices that Could Shape Illinois’ Individual Income Tax, examines the broader range of policy options available to the State and how decisions about tax design can produce substantially different outcomes for taxpayers and State finances.
The analysis examines three policy alternatives: modification to the existing flat tax, a high-income surcharge, and a graduated income tax. Within the existing flat-tax structure, the report examines adjustments to the uniform tax rate, expanded deductions and opportunities to broaden the tax base, including the taxation of retirement income. The analysis also evaluates a high-income surcharge, often referred to as a “millionaires’ tax,” that would impose an additional 3% tax on income above $1 million.
The report revisits Illinois’ 2020 proposal and introduces three models reflecting different policy priorities: Model A, which emphasizes moderate tax rates and economic competitiveness; Model B, which seeks to balance revenue generation and progressivity; and Model C, which prioritizes progressivity through greater tax relief in lower income brackets paired with higher marginal rates in upper brackets.
Notably, Illinois’ 2020 graduated income tax amendment, which the Civic Federation had opposed based on the proposed rate structure at the time, differs from the Model B graduated income tax structure outlined in this report. Both structures have top marginal rates of 7.99%. However, the 2020 amendment increased the marginal rate from 4.95% to 7.75% on income above $250,000, while Model B introduces more gradual rate increases and provides greater relief on income below $100,000.
The report does not endorse or recommend a specific proposal. Instead, it identifies the range of policy choices available and examines how different design decisions affect State revenues, the distribution of tax liability and economic competitiveness.
“With Illinois facing growing spending pressures and uncertainty surrounding federal funding, the need for a broader conversation about the State’s revenue structure is increasingly clear,” said Joe Ferguson, President of the Civic Federation. “That conversation must go beyond whether Illinois should have a flat or graduated income tax and consider the fiscal, economic and distributional implications of how the tax is designed.”
Each tax design presents different policy tradeoffs. Changes within the existing flat-tax structure could be implemented without a constitutional amendment but offer more limited flexibility in distributing tax liability across income levels. Tax relief could be offered through larger deductions, but this would require increasingly high uniform rates to raise equal amounts of revenue. A “millionaires’ tax” would increase taxes on a relatively small share of high-income taxpayers. However, the move is still considered regressive since it would not reduce taxes on those earning less. A graduated income tax would provide greater flexibility to adjust tax burdens across income levels but would introduce additional complexity. Both a high-income surcharge and a graduated income tax would require changes to the State’s constitution.
“With various income tax proposals up for debate in Illinois, we saw an opportunity to provide policymakers with a resource to help inform those conversations," said Senior Policy and Research Associate Lily Padula. "There are many ways to structure an income tax, and the decisions made about its design matter. We hope this report encourages a more thoughtful discussion of the options available to Illinois and the policy tradeoffs associated with each.”
Key Findings
- The highest rates don’t always generate the most revenue: Model C, an illustrative graduated structure with an 11.5% top marginal rate, generates an estimated $620 million in net new annual revenue, compared with $2.26 billion under Model B, which has a top marginal rate of 7.99%. But since Model C taxes lower-income brackets at a lower rate and increases the standard deduction, the tax structure produces less revenue than Model B.
- Gradual rates matter: Two structures with the same top rate can produce widely different revenues. Model B and the 2020 proposal both have 7.99% top marginal rates, but the revenue generated varies substantially because of differences in the rates and thresholds applied below the highest bracket.
- Providing tax relief while maintaining or increasing revenue involves tradeoffs: Larger deductions can be provided under a flat tax structure to reduce the amount of income subject to taxation, but require higher uniform rates to maintain existing revenue levels. Under the illustrative scenarios, increasing the deduction from 5,000/10,000 to 25,000/50,000 raises the revenue-neutral rate from 5.25% to 8.29%.
- Alongside this report, the Civic Federation has created an Illinois Income Tax Revenue Simulator, which lets you design alternative tax structures by adjusting income brackets, rates, exemptions and behavioral responses. The simulator allows users to see how different structures would affect households at varying income levels and estimates how much revenue each structure would raise compared with Illinois’ current 4.95% flat tax.
Read the Full Report
More Than a Tax Rate: Understanding the Choices that Could Shape Illinois’ Individual Income Tax